In the Daily Express today (November 19, 2026) there is a comprehensive analysis of the Piddington’s anger at the prospect of 1200+ young, male, unemployed men, or their successors, being housed for up to ten years in a rebuilt camp located on an abandoned military site in Oxfordshire very near them. . My last blog, published on 13 November looked at the lessons of planning failure Piddington high-lights. Interestingly the DT edition also contains Comments from Kemi Badenoch, Conservative leader and Zia Yusuf, ReformUK home affairs spokesman. Furthermore it also contains an editorial on the issues Piddington exposes. Overall its analysis provides food for thought. Piddington illustrates the failures of our democracy and its inability to one, produce long term solutions and two, to work across parties. Here, in no particular order, are some of the lessons of failure and the finally the truth that would remedy them.
- The brave women of Piddington aren’t Nimby’s. They are prophets. (DT leader). I agree. No other community would wish to emulate their example. Most unfairly they have gone some way to destroy their own village’s appeal as a location, and in so doing have sharply reduced the values of their own homes. Was this wise? Not in my opinion.
And their actions will be seen as prophetic in the years ahead as it becomes ever more clear our political leaders are unable to lead, when populist fears conflict with real world facts. The media’s love of conflict and disinterest in boring lessons is a slow burn poison. - Angry campaigners from Piddington declared they are fighting for the safety of all women-as Labour’s migrant plans camp plans are “dangerous for the rest of the country. (DT Exclusive, Michael Knowles). As a perception of reality this is a valid claim, clearly and vividly endorsed by protests around the country outside hotels used to house unauthorised immigrants. Market activity and market values are driven by perceptions of the truth, not necessarily the facts, and sometimes these perceptions lead to foolish claims by politicians seeking to exploit the menu of unpopular choices the government of the day faces.
- The Home Office said last night that other migrant camps…..have operated for years with “no evidence of rising crime”. (piece by Michael Knowles). No doubt true, in reality. But local people’s fears are not as I say driven by facts, but their perceptions. Dwell here on how this mind-set echoes the same set of fears that drives opposition to the building of new homes.
- These brave women have spent months ferociously campaigning against the Labour government’s callous plans. (Comment. Kemi Badenoch). And then goes on to say Labour’s politician’s are treating people’s homes and communities like dumping ground for problems the government can’t fix …. he should tackle the original issue: that these illegal immigrants are in the country in the first place.. Who can disagree with the sentiment behind these remarks by her? Except her own party too has a very recent history of failure in the two crucial areas , immigrants who are not wanted, and house which are not wanted. Her party failed from 2010 to 2024 to solve the housing supply problem, and actually made it worse by adopting two stupid policies: abolition of long term land use planning in 2011, and adopting a Cnut policy on immigration without cross- party support.
- Angela Rayner’s decision to force through plans to dump 1200 make migrants on a rural community of just 300 people – completely disregarding the concerns of residents and the safety of woman and girls -exposes a chilling contempt for the British people. (Comment. Zia Yusuf). He sings from Badenoch’s hymn book, but puts the injustice placed upon the residents of Piddington in sharp relief. No one will not share their concerns, despite Home Office reassurances. How many of us these days believe what we are told by any government? But he misleads too. To adopt ReformUK’s immigration policies we must leave the European Court, and make changes to our Westminster laws too. No small deal. The result then might be nasty in a country, unlike the USA, without a written constitution with a monarch as last resort who is desperate to stay out of politics come what may (remember Boris Johnson’s decision to prorogue Parliament in November 2019) ?
What are the lessons of Piddington? When it comes to decisions on land use change, whether the plan is to build houses, labs or factories, or change a derelict military site into a camp for restless, bored young men, a sudden decision, and sudden imposition of fundamental change in the neighbourhood which has not been preceded by a successful campaign to win over the local support , ie. the hearts and minds of the local hosts will fail. And fail whatever government as local residents put their entire asset base on the line to oppose the government. Translate this opposition to local land use change to my familiar example, building a new city of maybe one million over two generations in the Thames Valley with local support, or an urban, albeit scaled down in an urban equivalent like Richmond upon Thames. How in a hundred years is any government going to convince residents around Reading, Basingstoke, Farnborough and Wokingham on the one hand, or in London the residents of Richmond, Kingston, Hounslow and Teddington on the other to willingly plan for major lifetime land use change near them? Well, the answer is by making sure the opportunities for bigger and far better benefits to outweigh the negatives of change. This process of winning hearts and minds will take years and must be cross- party led. Is this too much to advocate? If so, future generations living in England face a bleak outlook as accommodation costs grow, the loved countryside and loved unban centres are renewed according to the haphazard vagaries of private land owners, in Piddington’s case the land owner is His Majesty’s Government. Who also happens be the planning authority. Which shows how fast land use could be delivered if the government was also the land owner. Lots of food for thought, thank you Piddington.
Ian Campbell
19 November 2026